CSAT Solved Papers/ 2021/Q52

2021 CSAT — Q52

Verbal Reading comprehension 2.5 marks Medium

Passage

Our cities are extremely vulnerable to climate change because of large concentrations of populations and poor infrastructure. Moreover, population densities are increasing in them but we have not yet developed the systems to address climate change impacts. Our cities contribute to 65 per cent of the GDP, but there are not enough facilities to cater to the needs of the people. It is important to address the issues of air quality, transport, etc., that are vital to identifying sustainable solutions. We need to involve citizens in city planning and create an ecosystem that meets the needs of the people.

Which among the following is the most logical and rational inference that can be made from the passage given above?

  1. A Our cities need to have well-defined administrative set-up with sufficient autonomy.
  2. B Ever increasing population densities is a hindrance in our efforts to achieve sustainable development.
  3. C To maintain and develop our cities we need to adopt sustainability related interventions. Answer
  4. D Public-Private Partnership mode of development is the viable long-term solution for the infrastructure and sustainability problems of India.

Thinking pathway

Locate. This asks for the best-supported inference: anchor it to the passage’s prescriptive lines. The passage: our cities are climate-vulnerable, lack systems and facilities, and so “it is important to address the issues of air quality, transport, etc., that are vital to identifying sustainable solutions,” and “we need to… create an ecosystem that meets the needs of the people.”

Test (find the line, then match it). The forced inference is the passage’s own call to action: sustainability-related interventions are needed to maintain and develop cities. (c) restates that directly.

Eliminate by anatomy. (b) is half right, half wrong — rising population density is named as a problem, but the passage’s inference is the remedy (sustainability interventions), not a verdict that density is the hindrance to sustainable development. (a) is not in the passage — “well-defined administrative set-up with autonomy” is a governance remedy the passage never mentions. (d) is not in the passage — “Public-Private Partnership mode” is a specific solution absent from the text. The transferable rule: when a passage diagnoses problems and then calls for a class of solutions, the inference is that class of solutions — here, sustainability interventions — not one isolated problem or an unmentioned remedy. Key: (c).

Evidence in the text

“It is important to address the issues of air quality, transport, etc., that are vital to identifying sustainable solutions. We need to involve citizens in city planning and create an ecosystem that meets the needs of the people.” — the passage’s whole prescription is sustainability-oriented intervention (air quality, transport, citizen-led planning) to maintain and develop cities → (c). (b) seizes one problem (density) and over-frames it as the hindrance; (a) “administrative autonomy” and (d) “PPP mode” are remedies the passage never raises.

Worked rationale

The passage frames cities as climate-vulnerable, under-served, and densifying, then prescribes addressing air quality and transport, involving citizens, and building a sustainable ecosystem.

  • (c) captures that prescription: adopt sustainability-related interventions to maintain and develop cities. Correct.
  • (b) elevates one named problem (density) into “the hindrance,” missing the remedy focus.
  • (a) invents administrative autonomy as the answer.
  • (d) invents the PPP mode as the solution.

Answer: (c).

Why the other options miss

  • A
    not in the passage: “administrative set-up with sufficient autonomy” is a governance remedy the passage never proposes.
  • B
    half right, half wrong: density is mentioned as a problem, but the passage’s inference is the call for sustainability interventions, not a verdict that density blocks sustainable development.
  • D
    not in the passage: “Public-Private Partnership mode… viable long-term solution” is a specific remedy nowhere in the passage.

Specialist insight

The trap is (b): it lifts a real phrase from the passage (“population densities are increasing”) and recasts it as the conclusion. But the passage names density as one of several problems and then pivots to its actual message — we need sustainability-oriented interventions. The most logical inference tracks that pivot to the remedy (c), not the lingering on one symptom (b). On “most logical inference” items, prefer the option that captures the passage’s prescriptive direction over one that freezes a single diagnosed problem.

The trap, in one line

(b) freezes one named problem (density); the passage pivots to its remedy — sustainability interventions to maintain and develop cities — so (c).

← All 2021 CSAT questions