CSAT Solved Papers/ 2022/Q10

2022 CSAT — Q10

Quant Number theory 2.5 marks Hard

The digits 11 to 99 are arranged in three rows in such a way that each row contains three digits, and the number formed in the second row is twice the number formed in the first row; and the number formed in the third row is thrice the number formed in the first row. Repetition of digits is not allowed. If only three of the four digits 2,3,72, 3, 7 and 99 are allowed to use in the first row, how many such combinations are possible to be arranged in the three rows?

  1. A 4
  2. B 3
  3. C 2 Answer
  4. D 1

Worked rationale

We need a 33-digit NN such that NN, 2N2N, 3N3N together use each of the digits 1199 exactly once (pandigital, no zeros). Since 3N3N must stay 33-digit, N333N \le 333.

The complete list of such NN is the classic set:

192 (384,576),219 (438,657),273 (546,819),327 (654,981).192\ (384, 576),\quad 219\ (438, 657),\quad 273\ (546, 819),\quad 327\ (654, 981).

Each verified pandigital. Now apply the extra rule: the first row NN must use only digits from {2,3,7,9}\{2,3,7,9\} (exactly three of those four):

  • 192192: digits {1,9,2}\{1,9,2\} — contains 11. Rejected.
  • 219219: digits {2,1,9}\{2,1,9\} — contains 11. Rejected.
  • 273273: digits {2,7,3}\{2,7,3\} — all in {2,3,7,9}\{2,3,7,9\}. Valid.
  • 327327: digits {3,2,7}\{3,2,7\} — all in {2,3,7,9}\{2,3,7,9\}. Valid.

Exactly two first-row numbers (273273 and 327327) satisfy the constraint.

Answer: (c) 2.

Why the other options miss

  • A
    solved the wrong question: counts all four pandigital triples and ignores the digit restriction on the first row.
  • B
    missed a case: drops only one of the 11-containing numbers, missing that both 192192 and 219219 are barred.
  • D
    missed a case: finds only one valid row (e.g. 273273) and stops before testing 327327.

Specialist insight

The hidden work is knowing — or quickly reconstructing — the four pandigital {N,2N,3N}\{N,2N,3N\} triples. Build them by the constraints N333N\le 333, no repeated/zero digits across all nine cells; the search is short because 2N,3N2N,3N being 33-digit pins NN between 100100 and 333333. The restriction “first row from {2,3,7,9}\{2,3,7,9\}” is then a pure filter that eliminates the two numbers carrying a 11.

The trap, in one line

Four pandigital triples exist; only 273273 and 327327 have a first row drawn from {2,3,7,9}\{2,3,7,9\} \Rightarrow (c).

← All 2022 CSAT questions