CSAT Solved Papers/ 2022/Q8

2022 CSAT — Q8

Quant Statement validity 2.5 marks Hard

A bill for Rs. 1,8401{,}840 is paid in the denominations of Rs. 5050, Rs. 2020 and Rs. 1010 notes. 5050 notes in all are used. Consider the following statements:

  1. 2525 notes of Rs. 5050 are used and the remaining are in the denominations of Rs. 2020 and Rs. 1010.

  2. 3535 notes of Rs. 2020 are used and the remaining are in the denominations of Rs. 5050 and Rs. 1010.

  3. 2020 notes of Rs. 1010 are used and the remaining are in the denominations of Rs. 5050 and Rs. 2020.

Which of the above statements are not correct?

  1. A 1 and 2 only
  2. B 2 and 3 only
  3. C 1 and 3 only
  4. D 1, 2 and 3 Answer

Worked rationale

Let a,b,ca, b, c be the counts of Rs. 5050, Rs. 2020, Rs. 1010 notes:

50a+20b+10c=1840,a+b+c=50.50a + 20b + 10c = 1840,\qquad a + b + c = 50.

Divide the first by 1010: 5a+2b+c=1845a + 2b + c = 184. Subtract a+b+c=50a+b+c=50:

4a+b=134b=1344a,c=50ab=3a84.4a + b = 134 \quad\Rightarrow\quad b = 134 - 4a,\quad c = 50 - a - b = 3a - 84.

Feasibility (b,c0b, c \ge 0): c0a28c \ge 0 \Rightarrow a \ge 28; b0a33b \ge 0 \Rightarrow a \le 33. So a{28,29,30,31,32,33}a \in \{28,29,30,31,32,33\} — and the Rs. 5050 count must be at least 2828.

Now test each claim:

  • Statement 1 (a=25a = 25): but a28a \ge 28 — impossible. Not correct.
  • Statement 2 (b=35b = 35): b=1344a=354a=99b = 134 - 4a = 35 \Rightarrow 4a = 99, not an integer — impossible. Not correct.
  • Statement 3 (c=20c = 20): c=3a84=203a=104c = 3a - 84 = 20 \Rightarrow 3a = 104, not an integer — impossible. Not correct.

All three fail.

Answer: (d) 1, 2 and 3.

Why the other options miss

  • A
    missed a case: catches the two infeasible counts but wrongly admits Statement 3 without checking 3a=1043a = 104 has no integer solution.
  • B
    missed a case: misses that a28a \ge 28 already kills Statement 1.
  • C
    an arithmetic slip: mis-solves 4a+b=1344a + b = 134 and accepts b=35b = 35.

Specialist insight

The whole problem collapses to one relation 4a+b=1344a + b = 134 and the feasibility window 28a3328 \le a \le 33. Each statement fixes one variable; you only have to check whether that value lands in range and yields integer partners. Two of the three fail an integrality test (99/499/4, 104/3104/3) and one fails the range bound (25<2825 < 28) — a clean reminder that “looks plausible” is not “is feasible.”

The trap, in one line

4a+b=1344a+b=134 forces a28a\ge 28 and integer partners; all of a=25a{=}25, b=35b{=}35, c=20c{=}20 break it \Rightarrow (d).

← All 2022 CSAT questions