CSAT Solved Papers/ 2023/Q26

2023 CSAT — Q26

Quant Arithmetic & numeracy 2.5 marks Medium

If p,q,rp, q, r and ss are distinct single digit positive numbers, then what is the greatest value of (p+q)(r+s)(p + q)(r + s)?

  1. A 230
  2. B 225 Answer
  3. C 224
  4. D 221

Worked rationale

Two moves: (1) choose the four largest distinct single-digit numbers, (2) split them so the two pair-sums are as equal as possible (a product of two numbers with fixed total is largest when they are equal).

Largest four distinct single digits: 9,8,7,69, 8, 7, 6, total =30= 30.

To maximise (p+q)(r+s)(p+q)(r+s) with (p+q)+(r+s)=30(p+q)+(r+s) = 30 fixed, make each pair sum 1515:

9+6=15,8+7=15(p+q)(r+s)=15×15=225.9 + 6 = 15,\qquad 8 + 7 = 15 \quad\Rightarrow\quad (p+q)(r+s) = 15 \times 15 = 225.

Any other split (e.g. 9+8=17, 7+6=1317×13=2219+8=17,\ 7+6=13 \Rightarrow 17\times 13 = 221) gives less.

Answer: (b) 225.

Why the other options miss

  • A
    missed a case: assumes the maximum is some unequal split or uses a digit larger than 99; 230230 is not attainable from four distinct single digits.
  • C
    an arithmetic slip: takes 16×14=22416 \times 14 = 224 from the split 9+7, 8+69+7,\ 8+6, which is not the most-equal split.
  • D
    the obvious-but-wrong pairing: uses the “extreme” split 9+8, 7+6=17×13=2219+8,\ 7+6 = 17\times 13 = 221, the natural but lopsided pairing rather than the most-equal one.

Specialist insight

Two layered optimisations: maximise the total (pick 9,8,7,69,8,7,6), then balance the two sums (fixed-sum products peak at equality, the AM–GM idea). The deadliest decoy is 221221 from the “obvious” pairing 9+89+8 with 7+67+6; the scoring move is to pair high-with-low (9+6, 8+79+6,\ 8+7) to hit 15×1515\times 15. Both ideas are needed — a candidate who balances but uses the wrong four digits, or picks the right digits but pairs them lopsidedly, loses the mark.

The trap, in one line

Take 9,8,7,69,8,7,6 and split to equal sums 9+69+6 and 8+78+7 (each 1515): 15×15=22515\times 15 = 225, beating the obvious 17×13=22117\times 13 = 221 \Rightarrow (b).

← All 2023 CSAT questions