CSAT Solved Papers/ 2024/Q10

2024 CSAT — Q10

Quant Logical & quantitative reasoning 2.5 marks Medium

On January 1st, 2023, a person saved 11 rupee. On January 2nd, 2023, he saved 22 rupees more than that on the previous day. On January 3rd, 2023, he saved 22 rupees more than that on the previous day and so on. At the end of which date was his total savings a perfect square as well a perfect cube?

  1. A 7th January, 2023
  2. B 8th January, 2023 Answer
  3. C 9th January, 2023
  4. D Not possible

Worked rationale

Daily savings form the AP 1,3,5,7,1, 3, 5, 7, \dots (first term 11, common difference 22) — the odd numbers. The cumulative total after nn days is the sum of the first nn odd numbers, a classic identity:

1+3+5++(2n1)=n2.1 + 3 + 5 + \cdots + (2n-1) = n^2.

So at the end of day nn the savings are exactly n2n^2already a perfect square for every nn. We need it to be a perfect cube too, i.e. n2n^2 must be a perfect sixth power, which forces nn itself to be a perfect cube.

The first non-trivial day is n=8n = 8 (=23=2^3): total =82=64=43= 8^2 = 64 = 4^3, a perfect square and a perfect cube. That is 8th January, 2023. (Day 77 gives 49=7249=7^2, not a cube; day 99 gives 81=9281=9^2, not a cube.)

Answer: (b) 8th January, 2023.

Why the other options miss

  • A
    the half-finished answer: stops at n=7n=7, 49=7249=7^2, mistaking the perfect square for the answer without checking the cube condition.
  • C
    missed a case: knows the total is n2n^2 but tests n=9n=9 (8181) by habit, missing that the cube condition needs nn a perfect cube, satisfied first at n=8n=8.
  • D
    solved the wrong question: fails to recognise 1+3+5+=n21+3+5+\cdots=n^2, so never sees that n=8n=8 makes the total 6464, both a square and a cube.

Specialist insight

The killer simplification is the identity sum of the first nn odds =n2= n^2 — it turns “add up the AP” into “is n2n^2 a cube?”. Since the total is always a square, the binding constraint is the cube: n2n^2 is a perfect cube     n\iff n is a perfect cube. The smallest cube past the trivial n=1n=1 is 88, so day 88 (64=2664=2^6) is the first date where savings are simultaneously a square and a cube. Spotting the odd-sum identity is worth far more than grinding the running total day by day.

The trap, in one line

The running total is n2n^2 (sum of odds), already a square — the real test is the cube, met first at n=8n=8 (total 64=4364=4^3), not at the perfect-square-looking day 77.

← All 2024 CSAT questions