CSAT Solved Papers/ 2025/Q25
2025 CSAT — Q25
Consider the first natural numbers. How many of them are not divisible by any one of and ?
Worked rationale
First prune the redundant divisor. Every multiple of is already a multiple of , so “not divisible by ” adds nothing once “not divisible by ” is imposed. The condition collapses to: not divisible by any of .
Count, by inclusion–exclusion, how many of – are divisible by at least one of :
Singles:
Pairs (subtract):
Triples (add):
Quad (subtract):
Not divisible by any: .
Answer: (c) 22. (These are together with the primes up to .)
Why the other options miss
- A missed a case: drops one or two triple-overlap terms (e.g. forgets ), under-counting the add-back.
- B counted one too few: forgets to count (which is divisible by none), giving just the primes .
- D an arithmetic slip: in the pair sum (e.g. read as ), nudging the final count up by one.
Specialist insight
The exam-fast move is killing the redundant divisor before any counting: is a subset condition of , so four-way inclusion–exclusion ( terms) shrinks to the cleaner three-way-plus-one over . Mishandling the — either double-removing its multiples or running a needless -term — is the engineered error. Under the clock, also sanity-check the answer structurally: the survivors are exactly and the primes in , of which there are , so total — a fast independent confirmation of the inclusion–exclusion arithmetic.
"Not divisible by " is redundant given "not divisible by " — reduce to , then inclusion–exclusion gives .