CSAT Solved Papers/ 2025/Q7

2025 CSAT — Q7

Quant Number theory 2.5 marks Medium

How many possible values of (p+q+r)(p + q + r) are there satisfying 1p+1q+1r=1\dfrac{1}{p} + \dfrac{1}{q} + \dfrac{1}{r} = 1, where pp, qq and rr are natural numbers (not necessarily distinct)?

  1. A None
  2. B One
  3. C Three Answer
  4. D More than three

Worked rationale

Order them pqrp \le q \le r and bound the smallest denominator. Since the three terms sum to 11, the largest term 1p\tfrac1p is at least 13\tfrac13, so p3p \le 3; and 1p<1\tfrac1p < 1 forces p2p \ge 2. Hence p{2,3}p \in \{2,3\}.

Case p=3p = 3: then 1q+1r=23\tfrac1q+\tfrac1r = \tfrac23 with q3q \ge 3. Now 1q13\tfrac1q \ge \tfrac13 forces q=3q = 3, giving 1r=13\tfrac1r = \tfrac13, so r=3r = 3. Solution (3,3,3)(3,3,3), sum =9= 9.

Case p=2p = 2: then 1q+1r=12\tfrac1q+\tfrac1r = \tfrac12 with q2q \ge 2. Bounding 1q14\tfrac1q \ge \tfrac14 gives q{3,4}q \in \{3,4\}:

  • q=31r=16r=6q = 3 \Rightarrow \tfrac1r = \tfrac16 \Rightarrow r = 6: solution (2,3,6)(2,3,6), sum =11= 11.
  • q=41r=14r=4q = 4 \Rightarrow \tfrac1r = \tfrac14 \Rightarrow r = 4: solution (2,4,4)(2,4,4), sum =10= 10.

The three unordered solutions are (3,3,3), (2,4,4), (2,3,6)(3,3,3),\ (2,4,4),\ (2,3,6), giving sums {9,10,11}\{9, 10, 11\}three distinct values of p+q+rp+q+r.

Answer: (c) Three.

Why the other options miss

  • A
    solved the wrong question: assumes no integer solution exists (confusing “not necessarily distinct” with “must be distinct,” where only (2,3,6)(2,3,6) survives).
  • B
    missed a case: finds the symmetric (3,3,3)(3,3,3) and stops, missing the two solutions with p=2p = 2.
  • D
    answered the sub-step, not the question: counts ordered triples (permutations: 1+3+6=101 + 3 + 6 = 10 arrangements) instead of distinct values of the sum, which the question actually asks for.

Specialist insight

The engine of every unit-fraction equation is the bounding move: with pqrp \le q \le r, the smallest denominator is squeezed into a tiny range (pk/(RHS)p \le k/(\text{RHS})). Here it pins p{2,3}p \in \{2,3\} in one line and the rest cascades. The planted trap is the ordered-vs-unordered confusion in option (d): the triples number more than three, but the question asks how many distinct values of the sum — and that is exactly {9,10,11}=3|\{9,10,11\}| = 3. Read the target quantity precisely before counting.

The trap, in one line

Count distinct values of the sum ({9,10,11}\{9,10,11\} = three), not ordered triples — and don't stop at the symmetric solution (3,3,3)(3,3,3).

← All 2025 CSAT questions